The verdict up front: Superads and Motion are both good at reporting what your ads did, and Peachblue is built to help you make more winning ads next. Peachblue starts at $79 a month and, across its plans, covers Meta, TikTok, Google Ads, and Amazon DSP, gives every creative a written read across 31 dimensions, turns what your winners share into the brief for the next round, and puts your data in Claude. Superads is the pick when live, shareable boards across Meta, TikTok, LinkedIn, and Google Ads are the whole job, at $150 a month. Motion is the pick when your team lives in Slack and wants the category's strongest education ecosystem, at $999 a month.
Superads was re-checked on its live pricing and product pages on October 27, 2026, and Motion on October 25, 2026. Much of what ranks for this comparison is out of date: Superads' own comparison material still prices Motion at $250 a month, and Motion's Starter has been $999 since at least October 21.
The comparison at a glance
| Superads | Motion | Peachblue | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price | $150/mo ($125 billed yearly) | $999/mo (Starter) | $79/mo (Starter) |
| Higher tiers | +$100/mo per extra $100k of spend; Enterprise custom | Pro and Growth on request | $199 / $499 / $799; Agency priced to your client roster |
| Pricing gates on | Monthly ad spend | Monthly ad spend | Features and analysis credits |
| Trial | 14 days | Free trial, no card | 7 days on Starter and Pro |
| Seats | Unlimited users | Unlimited seats and ad accounts | 1 to 25 by tier |
| Platforms | Meta, TikTok, LinkedIn, Google Ads (incl. Performance Max) | Meta, TikTok, YouTube, LinkedIn | Meta, TikTok, Google Ads, Amazon DSP |
| Creative analysis | Superads Scores on five dimensions, AI tags | AI tags, ad leaderboard | 31 dimensions, written read and copy suggestions per creative |
| What to make next | Superads AI suggestions, scheduled Workflows | Briefs and hooks in Slack | Next Creative Brief with a generation-ready prompt |
| Waste and fatigue | Fatigue alerts via Workflows | Alerts in Slack | Hit rate, wasted spend in dollars, fatigue against each creative's best week |
| MCP for Claude | Not currently, per its own blog | From Starter | Pro and up, including Amazon DSP data |
| Reddit brand monitoring | Not listed | No | Brand Intel |
| Agency infrastructure | Client boards, multi-account reports | No multi-client mode | Multi-client workspaces, margin-aware reports, DSP and CTV pacing |
| Sharing | Live interactive boards, guests | Live-data reports, view-only guests on Pro | PDF and CSV reports, shareable brief links |
| Competitor ad tracking | Inspiration | Inspo | Competitor ads comparison coming soon |
Prices verified October 27, 2026 (Superads) and October 25, 2026 (Motion); Peachblue from our live pricing page.
How much do Superads, Motion, and Peachblue cost?
Peachblue runs $79 to $799 a month self-serve, plus an Agency tier priced to your client roster. Superads Professional is $150 a month, or $125 billed yearly, for up to $100k of monthly ad spend, plus $100 a month for each extra $100k. Motion's Starter is $999 a month for up to $50k of monthly ad spend, with Pro and Growth priced on request.
Superads and Motion price on the ad spend they analyze. Peachblue prices on features and monthly analysis credits, so what you pay tracks how much creative you analyze, not how much media you buy. Features unlock by plan: Starter covers Meta and TikTok, Pro ($199) adds Google Ads, Intelligence, Brand Intel, and the MCP server, Scale ($499) adds Amazon DSP, Power ($799) adds Reports and Pacing, and Agency adds multi-client workspaces. Annual plans get two months free. Size your credits to your creative volume before you pick a tier.
For comparison on spend: at $300k a month, Superads works out to $350 by its published formula (our arithmetic), and Motion's price is a sales conversation.
Which platforms does each one cover?
Peachblue covers Meta, TikTok, Google Ads (Search, Display, and Video), and Amazon DSP. Superads covers Meta, TikTok, LinkedIn, and Google Ads including Performance Max. Motion covers Meta, TikTok, YouTube, and LinkedIn.
Only Peachblue covers Amazon DSP: it is the only creative analytics platform for agencies at self-serve pricing that does, with performance, pacing, and reports beside your social and search creative. Superads is the one that pairs LinkedIn with Performance Max, though one of its own blog posts still calls Google Ads beta, and Motion is the one with YouTube. Peachblue also recognizes the same creative across ads and platforms by its visual fingerprint, so a video running as a 9:16, a 1:1, and a re-cut on Meta and TikTok counts as one creative with one set of results, and your hit rate is real.
Which one helps you make more winning ads?
All three tag your creative with AI. The difference is what happens after the tags, and this is where Peachblue is built differently.
Superads gives each creative a 0 to 100 score on Hook, Hold, Click, Engagement, and Conversion against your own account, and Superads AI answers questions over your data, on demand or on a schedule through Workflows. Motion's always-on AI brain watches and tags everything you run and pushes briefs, hooks, reports, and alerts into Slack on routines.
Peachblue gives every creative a written expert read across 31 dimensions (format, hook style, emotional tone, CTA type, and more) with copy suggestions, and a composite score that blends CTR, ROAS, CPA, and spend. The Intelligence layer finds the patterns and archetypes your winners share, and the Next Creative Brief turns them into what to make next: the winning recipe, concepts, proven hooks from your own headlines, do and don't rules with cohort counts, labeled reference ads, and a prompt block you can paste into an image or video generator. The Today and Creative Economics views track your creative hit rate, the dollars spent on losers, and fatigue measured against each creative's own best week. That is the loop that makes more winners: moving your hit rate from 10% to 20% doubles your winners from the same test budget.
Can you use them from Claude?
Peachblue and Motion, yes; Superads, not currently. Superads' own blog answers "Does Superads have an MCP connector?" with "Not currently", and its AI lives inside its app, Slack, and email.
Motion includes an MCP server from Starter. Peachblue's MCP server, on Pro and up, exposes the same 23 read-only tools as Agent Peach, our in-app agent: rankings, comparisons, patterns, fatigue and spend risk, Amazon DSP pacing and suppliers, client comparison, and Brand Intel's Reddit mentions. It is the only creative analytics MCP that serves your own cross-platform performance data, including Amazon DSP, and you connect it by signing in with your Peachblue account. The wider field is in best MCP servers for ad data.
Which is best for agencies?
Peachblue, for agencies that run creative and Amazon DSP for a roster of clients. Its Agency tier has multi-client workspaces with a client switcher, per-client reports with your agency margin applied, Amazon DSP and CTV flight pacing, per-client intelligence and brand monitoring, and 25 seats.
Superads is the strongest of the three at sharing: client boards, reports that combine several ad accounts, and live interactive links with named guests and unlimited users. Motion has no multi-client mode, though its unlimited seats and ad accounts and its live-data reports make it workable for agency teams. Neither Superads nor Motion applies agency margin to client reports or paces DSP flights. The full agency field is in best creative analytics tools for agencies.
What Superads and Motion are known for
Superads is known for sharing: live boards that clients can sort and filter, guest access, and unlimited users on its one plan. It is also the one here that covers LinkedIn and Performance Max, it sends scheduled AI summaries to Slack or email through Workflows, and it tracks competitor ads in Inspiration.
Motion is known for its Slack-native routines and for the best education ecosystem in the category: the Thumbstop newsletter, courses, and events, most of it free to everyone whether or not you buy the software. It covers YouTube, tracks competitor ads in Inspo, and adds Northbeam and Google Analytics attribution integrations at Pro.
Peachblue's competitor ads comparison is coming soon. Until it ships, Peachblue analyzes your own ads.
Who should pick which
Superads, if your job is reporting across LinkedIn and Google Ads, including Performance Max, and sharing live boards with clients or leadership, and you don't need your data in Claude.
Motion, if your team buys on social, lives in Slack, and values the education ecosystem around its vendor.
Peachblue, if your job is making more winning ads, on Meta alone or across Google Ads and Amazon DSP. You get a written read of every creative, the next brief built from your own winners, your hit rate and wasted spend in dollars, your data in Claude, and Reddit monitoring for your brand. For agencies, it adds client workspaces with margin and DSP pacing. Starter is $79 a month with a 7-day trial; see pricing.
The one-pass version
- Make more winning ads, not just report on them: Peachblue.
- Amazon DSP anywhere in the plan: Peachblue, the only one of the three that covers it.
- Google Ads and Claude in the same tool: Peachblue; Superads has Google Ads without MCP, and Motion has MCP without Google Ads.
- Agency with client reporting and DSP pacing: Peachblue.
- Live boards across LinkedIn and Performance Max: Superads.
- Slack-native routines and the education ecosystem: Motion.
- Still comparing: Peachblue vs Motion, Superads alternatives, and all fourteen tools compared.